It didn’t take the protest at Dior to understand Stella McCartney

It didn’t take the protest at Dior to understand Stella McCartney

Glitz.Paris seems surprised. After disrupting New York Fashion Week on September 13 with a protest against Cos’s use of wool, PETA turned its attention to Dior, which it holds morally responsible for using feathers. Then, outside the maison’s Paris show on September 28, it staged the symbolic plucking of an ostrich/model. Nothing surprising there, one might say: it’s PETA doing what it often does, trying to steal the spotlight at high-society events. What surprises Glitz.Paris, however, is that the vegan organization has Stella McCartney’s political and media support in this battle against feathers.

Stella McCartney against Dior

Ingratitude. From the admittedly naive perspective of Glitz.Paris, it’s strange that the British designer would take such an adverse, if not openly hostile, stance toward a maison controlled by LVMH. This is the same holding company that, until 2025, held a stake in Stella McCartney and, above all, contributed generously to keeping her business afloat. That’s why the position can look ungrateful. Those who know her better would add: it didn’t take the Dior feathers case to understand that Stella is a very poor interlocutor for the fashion system.

Vegan moral superiority

After all, Stella has long used her platform to attack not only feathers, but all animal-derived materials used by her partners, including those in which they had also invested, even as she benefited first from Kering’s support and then from LVMH’s. She does so without nuance, following the binary logic typical of ideological positions. On one side, she places materials she sees as bad and irredeemable: feathers, wool, leather, exotic skins and so on. On the other, she places what she considers good: mostly synthetic or next-generation materials, at least for as long as they stayed on the market. Didn’t such positions embarrass the French holding companies, which own tanneries, farms and spinning mills? Those were years of booming revenue growth, and the holding companies lived with her extremism without batting an eye. But that was already ingratitude. It’s always been that way.

Photo from Dior

Read also:

 

PREMIUM CONTENT

Choose one of our subscription plans

Do you want to receive our newsletter?
Subscribe now
×